Users vs. Aliases: Choosing the Best Setup for Your Needs

Created by Curtis Hammock, Modified on Sun, 15 Nov at 7:22 PM by Curtis Hammock

When setting up email addresses on your custom domain, should you create a User or use a Routing Rule ("Alias")?

In Purelymail, you do not create separate "alias" objects (see Admin Accounts vs. Users vs. Aliases Explained). Any address that simply forwards to an existing mailbox or external email is configured as a Routing Rule under the Routing tab, or handled automatically through Symbolic Subaddressing.


Summary Comparison

Requirement Use a User (Mailbox) Use a Routing Rule ("Alias")
Needs its own separate login credentials Yes No
Needs its own private inbox & storage Yes No
Forwards mail to an existing internal or external address No Yes
Distributes mail to multiple team members at once No Yes
Temporary or tagged address for signups / newsletters No Yes (or automatic Subaddressing)
Cost on Custom Domains Included on Simple Plan; storage-based on Advanced Plan Free & Unlimited

1. When to Create a User (Mailbox)

Create a User under Users (see How to Create and Manage Users (Mailboxes)) when an email address needs:

  • Dedicated login credentials (user@yourdomain.com) for Webmail or IMAP/SMTP apps.
  • Isolated message storage, folders, contacts, and calendars.
  • Individual Two-Factor Authentication (2FA), App Passwords, or User Sieve filters.
  • Examples: Personal mailboxes for yourself, family members, employees, or a shared inbox with centralized read/sent state (see How to Set Up Shared Mailboxes & Team Inboxes).

2. When to Use a Routing Rule ("Alias" Functionality)

Create a Routing Rule under Routing (see How to Create Email Aliases & Forwarding Rules) when an address:

  • Should deliver incoming mail into one or more existing mailboxes without requiring a separate login.
  • Acts as a role or department address (such as billing@, press@, or sales@) delivering to your main inbox.
  • Acts as a domain prefix rule or catch-all rule (*@yourdomain.com; see Setting Up Catch-All Rules and Domain Prefix Routing).

3. When to Use Symbolic Subaddressing (No Setup Required)

If you want a disposable or tagged address (for example, for online shopping receipts or newsletters):

  • No setup is required. Purelymail automatically routes yourname+tag@yourdomain.com and yourname_tag@yourdomain.com directly to yourname@yourdomain.com (see Understanding Symbolic Subaddressing).

Still Need Help?

If you've followed these steps and are still running into trouble, check our Purelymail Support guide.

Was this article helpful?

That’s Great!

Thank you for your feedback

Sorry! We couldn't be helpful

Thank you for your feedback

Let us know how can we improve this article!

Select at least one of the reasons
CAPTCHA verification is required.

Feedback sent

We appreciate your effort and will try to fix the article